A comparison of cellulosic fuel yields and separated soil-surface CO2 fluxes in maize and prairie biofuel cropping systems
نویسندگان
چکیده
We investigated potential use of prairie as a Midwestern cellulosic feedstock by conducting a 9 ha side-by-side comparison of maizeand prairie-based systems on fertile soils in Boone County Iowa, USA. Investigated systems were: maize-soybean rotation grown for grain only, continuous maize grown for grain and stover both with and without a winter rye cover crop, and a 31-species reconstructed prairie grown with and without spring nitrogen fertilization for fall-harvested biomass. We compared amounts of cellulosic biomass produced and harvested, ethanol conversion ratios of biomass as measured by both dietary and detergent methodology, as well as each method’s estimated ethanol yields per unit land area. From 2009-2013, the highest producing system was N-fertilized prairie, averaging 10.4 Mg ha yr above-ground biomass with average harvest removals of 7.8 Mg ha yr. The unfertilized prairie produced 7.4 Mg ha yr, with average harvests of 5.3 Mg ha yr. Lowest cellulosic biomass harvests were realized from continuous maize systems, averaging 3.5 Mg ha yr when grown with, and 3.7 Mg ha yr when grown without a winter rye cover crop, respectively. Un-fertilized prairie biomass and maize stover had equivalent dietary conversion ratios at 330 g ethanol kg dry biomass, but N-fertilized prairie was lower at 315. Detergent method over-prediction depended upon both growing environment and biomass source. Harvested biomass accounted for >90% of ethanol yield variation. Over four years prairie systems averaged 1287 L cellulosic ethanol ha yr more than maize systems, with fertilization increasing prairie ethanol production by 865 L ha yr . On both a biomass-per-unit-land area and ethanol-per-unit biomass basis, the reconstructed prairies met or surpassed cellulosic standards set by maize cellulosic systems, indicating prairies could function as an industrial cellulosic feedstock in the Midwest.
منابع مشابه
Soil physical properties, soil carbon dioxide fluxes, and soil drainage dynamics of select bioenergy cropping systems
Bioenergy cropping systems have been proposed as a way to enhance United States energy security. However, research on soil physical properties, soil-surface CO2 effluxes, and soil drainage dynamics in such systems is needed to ensure environmental sustainability in the field. The objective of our research was to evaluate soil physical properties and conditions as well as soil-surface CO2 efflux...
متن کاملCover crops have neutral effects on predator communities and biological control services in annual cellulosic bioenergy cropping systems
Maize stover is beginning to be used as a cellulosic biofuel feedstock in the Midwestern United States; however, there are concerns that stover removal could result in increased soil erosion and loss of soil organic matter. Use of a winter cover crop following maize harvest has the potential to mitigate these impacts and may have additional benefits by providing continuous living cover in annua...
متن کاملThe biogeochemistry of bioenergy landscapes: carbon, nitrogen, and water considerations.
The biogeochemical liabilities of grain-based crop production for bioenergy are no different from those of grain-based food production: excessive nitrate leakage, soil carbon and phosphorus loss, nitrous oxide production, and attenuated methane uptake. Contingent problems are well known, increasingly well documented, and recalcitrant: freshwater and coastal marine eutrophication, groundwater po...
متن کاملEnergy Potential and Greenhouse Gas Emissions from Bioenergy Cropping Systems on Marginally Productive Cropland
Low-carbon biofuel sources are being developed and evaluated in the United States and Europe to partially offset petroleum transport fuels. Current and potential biofuel production systems were evaluated from a long-term continuous no-tillage corn (Zea mays L.) and switchgrass (Panicum virgatum L.) field trial under differing harvest strategies and nitrogen (N) fertilizer intensities to determi...
متن کاملThe effects of strip cropping and weed control methods on yields of dent maize, narrow-leafed lupin and oats
The aim of this study was to assess the effects of strip cropping and different weed control methods on the yield and yield structure of dent maize, narrow-leafed lupin and spring oat. A split-plot design with four replications was conducted in 2008-2010. The following factors were analysed in the experiment: I. Cultivation method – sole cropping and strip cropping; II. Weed control method ...
متن کامل